Governance Indicator Matrix

28 indicators · 7 dimensions · CLAAM framework

Fiscal Autonomy

GAAI weight 20% · 4 indicators

Fiscal Dependency Ratio
% · ↓ better

Share of MMDA revenue from central transfers.

Internally Generated Funds Share
% · ↑ better

Share of revenue raised locally.

Budget Execution Rate
% · ↑ better

Actual expenditure as share of approved budget.

Timeliness of Central Transfers
days · ↓ better

Average delay in receipt of statutory transfers.

Administrative Independence

GAAI weight 15% · 4 indicators

Local Decision Autonomy Score
idx · ↑ better

Composite of bylaw and procurement autonomy.

Staff Capacity Ratio
% · ↑ better

Filled technical positions vs. establishment.

Policy Implementation Timeliness
% · ↑ better

Policies implemented on schedule.

Interdepartmental Coordination Score
idx · ↑ better

Inter-departmental workflow performance.

Transparency

GAAI weight 15% · 4 indicators

Public Budget Disclosure Rate
% · ↑ better

Budgets published within statutory window.

Procurement Transparency Index
idx · ↑ better

Procurement records published and machine-readable.

Open Data Accessibility Score
idx · ↑ better

Datasets published in open formats.

Audit Publication Timeliness
days · ↓ better

Days between audit completion and publication.

Citizen Participation

GAAI weight 15% · 4 indicators

Citizen Engagement Rate
% · ↑ better

Citizens engaging via official channels.

Town Hall Participation Rate
% · ↑ better

Attendance at statutory town halls.

Complaint Submission Rate
per10k · ↑ better

Complaints filed per 10,000 residents.

Participatory Budgeting Inclusion Rate
% · ↑ better

Budget allocations decided participatorily.

Responsiveness

GAAI weight 10% · 4 indicators

Complaint Resolution Time
days · ↓ better

Median days to resolve complaints.

Service Request Fulfillment Rate
% · ↑ better

Service requests fulfilled within SLA.

Policy Response Efficiency
idx · ↑ better

Speed of council response to citizen petitions.

Emergency Response Time
min · ↓ better

Average emergency dispatch time.

Service Delivery

GAAI weight 10% · 4 indicators

Project Completion Rate
% · ↑ better

Capital projects completed on time.

Infrastructure Functionality Rate
% · ↑ better

Infrastructure assets in functional condition.

Education Service Coverage
% · ↑ better

Coverage of basic education services.

Water and Sanitation Access
% · ↑ better

Households with safe water and sanitation.

Governance Trust

GAAI weight 15% · 4 indicators

Citizen Trust Index
idx · ↑ better

Survey-derived trust in local government.

Institutional Legitimacy Score
idx · ↑ better

Perceived legitimacy of institutions.

Public Satisfaction Rating
% · ↑ better

Satisfaction with municipal services.

Governance Confidence Index
idx · ↑ better

Confidence in governance trajectory.